Saturday, July 2, 2016

Human Variation: High Altitude

            High altitude affects many people, past and present, around the world. Often, high altitudes have dangerous effects on people who are not used to it. It may cause hypoxia in many people due to the lack of oxygen that is being supplied to the lungs (There is not less oxygen at higher altitudes, it is just less concentrated). This is because as the altitude increases, air pressure decreases making it harder for oxygen to permeate the lung membrane. Among others, consequences include difficulty breathing, headaches, vomiting, and fatigue. Fortunately, our bodies have been perfecting ways to deal with the stress of changing altitudes.

            Short-term adaptions to hypoxia and other altitude sicknesses are vomiting, fatigue, and headaches. As our bodies are receiving less oxygen, they do their best to compensate and, in turn, indulge minor pains (like the headaches) rather than something more severe like death. This is considered a short-term adaption because the symptoms of altitude sickness disappear once the person suffering returns to his or her normal environment.

            A developmental adaption to high altitude is the increased production of hemoglobin in the blood. The high level of hemoglobin in blood permits higher levels of oxygen to be transported to the lungs, in addition to increasing lung expansion. After hundreds of generations of dealing with the lack of oxygen, Tibetans have perfected this development from birth, resulting in rosy cheeks. People who have lived at high altitudes for many generations will certainly have redder cheeks from birth than those who have only lived there for a short time.

            A facultative response to high altitude is heightened fitness. Many athletes training for the Olympics are often coached at much higher altitudes than their normal environments, because they believe it will result in a “short-term developmental” adaption. As discussed above, with lower oxygen levels and air pressure cause hemoglobin production to increase. This process allows athletes to gain a normal fitness standard while at higher altitudes, and consequently enhanced fitness at lower altitudes. However, their bodies have not been structured to continue doing this like Tibetans and their enhanced fitness soon fades back to normal.

            A cultural adaptation to high altitude is the practice of yoga and meditation by Nepalese Buddhist monks. The deep breathing helps transport oxygen to the lungs at a normal rate. Studies by the High Altitude Medical Research Centre have concluded that yoga and deep breathing can reduce the effects of hypoxia in those who practice it regularly.


            Studying human variation from this perspective allows us to understand how our bodies adapt and function under different conditions. Scientists can see how bodies adapt to the different environments and further understand what the environments may have been like in the past. These studies also indicate that race would have no explanation for the genetic changes seen across environmental clines. The changes that have occurred genotypically and phenotypically are results of people living in an area for a long period of time, regardless of who they were "racially." Race is a poor way to study adaptations, because there are so many similarities between racial groups. Race itself is made up in order to describe people who look different from one another, although there is more genetic variation within a single racial group than between multiple. Environmental stresses are the best way to understand the causes for skin color and many other genetic variations seen around the world.

9 comments:

  1. Nice post. I like how you said that race is a poor way to study adaptations. This is true because race doesn't tell us why people adapted the way they did. I like how you got into detail when describing the short-term adaptation, the developmental adaptation, the facultative adaptation, and the cultural adaptation. It's really interesting to me that Buddhist monks practice yoga and meditation through deep breathing to reduce hypoxia.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Olivia.
    Good job on your blog. I also chose to do high altitude adaptations because I thought it was very interesting to learn about. For all of your adaptations I got the same examples as you except for developmental. I enjoyed reading about your different adaptations for development because it was different then mine.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Olivia,
    This is a really well put together blog. I really like the cultural references about yoga. I really believe in the benefits of yoga and it's funny to think that these health benefits originated because humans were adapting to high altitudes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great examples on describing high altitude. Race is a poor way to depend on studies when our environment influences on one another with the levels of altitude for the human variation.

    Great Job!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Olivia,
    Your blog was very well written. I enjoyed reading it. Good job! You had many great examples for describing high altitudes. All your different adaptions were very well written and I loved the pictures.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Olivia,
    Your blog was very well written. I enjoyed reading it. Good job! You had many great examples for describing high altitudes. All your different adaptions were very well written and I loved the pictures.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very good description of high altitude stress. Are there any concerns faces by pregnant women faced with this stress?

    NOTE: The term "adaptation" means a positive way the body adjusts to a particular stress in a way that *helps* the body. So how does "vomiting, fatigue, and headaches" help the body? These aren't adaptation. They are indications that the body ISN'T adapting the high altitude stress.

    A short-term adaptation to high altitude stress is an increased respiration rate.

    Another note: Short-term, facultative and developmental traits are all automatic physiological responses to a particular stress. There is no need for a person to consciously act to produce these responses. They happen regardless.

    Given that, rethink your suggestion for a facultative response. Increasing fitness requires a conscious response and a decision to exercise more. That would be a possible cultural adaptation, but not a facultative response.

    A facultative response to high altitude stress is an increase in production of blood cells, to help carry more oxygen to the body tissues. No thought is required in this response. It is an automatic physiological process involving turning on the genes that help produce more blood cells. That defines a facultative response.

    You have identified increased hemoglobin production as a developmental trait. As explained, this is a facultative response.

    A developmental adaptation, requiring genetic change over many generations, is the development of a short, broad chest with a larger lung capacity. Populations such as the Andean and Tibetan populations also develop genetic changes that help them use the oxygen available to them more efficiently.

    I suggest that you return to this week's module and review the information there that outlines these adaptations.

    Good choice of a cultural response.

    Okay on your discussion of the benefits of using the adaptive approach, but can you think of any concrete benefits? Could what we learn from this approach have implications in the medical field?

    "Race itself is made up in order to describe people who look different from one another, although there is more genetic variation within a single racial group than between multiple."

    That's what I'm looking for. Race is not a biological construct. It is a sociocultural concept, with no basis in biology, subject to the biases and preconceptions of each culture. Each culture has it's own system of race... so which definition of race should we use? If it has no basis in biology, how can race be used to understand the biology of our human variation?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Olivia, well written blog, I always thought there was less oxygen in high altitudes thanks you for clarifying that. I also like how you incorporated different ways of how people adapt to high altitude. I also agree that race cannot be used to study human variation.

    ReplyDelete